Forums HomeRegisterSearchFAQRulesUsergroupsLog in
StarCraft II One sided?
PDXLAN Forum Index » PC Games Discussion All times are UTC - 8 hours Reply to topic
Author Message
Facilitator
Private 1st Class
Private 1st Class




Posts: 49

StarCraft II One sided? Reply with quote
Is it just me or does it look like the Protoss have Uber units compared to Terran?? The way they present it the Mother ship are the best thing since sliced cheese. It just doesn't seem fare to make Protoss the best again...

_________________
Being pwnd is what I do best.
Mon Sep 10, 2007 12:33 pm
View user's profile Send private message   XFire Address Post
Spork
Webmasterer
Colonel (Staff)
Colonel (Staff)




Posts: 4234

Location:
Hillsboro, OR

Reply with quote
In my opinion it looks like the idea is to have economy be the balance. Sure the protos may have the uber units but the human units could be cheaper, kind of a zergling type thing.

Only time will tell, I look forward to getting to play when it's released. Smile

_________________
I'll be honest, we're throwing science at the wall here to see what sticks. No idea what it'll do.
Mon Sep 10, 2007 1:22 pm
View user's profile Send private message   Visit poster's website Post
Xelmon
Captain
Captain




Posts: 3277

Location:
P-town, Oregon

Reply with quote
Spork wrote:
Only time will tell, I look forward to getting to play when it's released. Smile
Thank god sooner then Duke Nukem Fornever

_________________
"Over specialize and you breed in weakness... It's slow death."
Mjr. Kusanagi, GitS 1
Mon Sep 10, 2007 1:40 pm
View user's profile Send private message   XFire Address ICQ Number Post
Endres
Warrant Officer
Warrant Officer




Posts: 262

Reply with quote
On the starcraft2 website they only show like half of the protoss units, around 1/3 of the terran units, and no zerg units have been released yet. Protoss has been pretty much the main race shown off at these few presentations for a game thats ETA is over a year away so you can't judge the entire game on this. Protoss is not overpowered and Starcraft will probably go down as the most balanced game made.
Mon Sep 10, 2007 3:01 pm
View user's profile Send private message   Post
Church
Specialist
Specialist




Posts: 128

Location:
Eugene, Or

Re: StarCraft II One sided? Reply with quote
Facilitator wrote:
Is it just me or does it look like the Protoss have Uber units compared to Terran?? The way they present it the Mother ship are the best thing since sliced cheese. It just doesn't seem fare to make Protoss the best again...


Protoss weren't the best.

They've developed the Protoss more than the other races so far. It's not even close to release yet.

_________________
"This kind of mob stupidity might be the best evidence around that mankind evolved from cows rather than apes."
— Slashdot user on a post about Black Friday
Mon Sep 10, 2007 3:07 pm
View user's profile Send private message   AIM Address XFire Address Post
Facilitator
Private 1st Class
Private 1st Class




Posts: 49

Re: StarCraft II One sided? Reply with quote
Church wrote:


Protoss weren't the best.

They've developed the Protoss more than the other races so far. It's not even close to release yet.


You get to even matched players one on Terran and the other on Protoss and Protoss will win almost every time.

_________________
Being pwnd is what I do best.
Mon Sep 10, 2007 5:18 pm
View user's profile Send private message   XFire Address Post
Xelmon
Captain
Captain




Posts: 3277

Location:
P-town, Oregon

Re: StarCraft II One sided? Reply with quote
Facilitator wrote:
Church wrote:
Protoss weren't the best.

They've developed the Protoss more than the other races so far. It's not even close to release yet.
You get to even matched players one on Terran and the other on Protoss and Protoss will win almost every time.
That might be true... Point of the game, especially being a terran is to be sneaky or to have absolute brute force.

_________________
"Over specialize and you breed in weakness... It's slow death."
Mjr. Kusanagi, GitS 1
Mon Sep 10, 2007 11:07 pm
View user's profile Send private message   XFire Address ICQ Number Post
Church
Specialist
Specialist




Posts: 128

Location:
Eugene, Or

Re: StarCraft II One sided? Reply with quote
Facilitator wrote:
Church wrote:


Protoss weren't the best.

They've developed the Protoss more than the other races so far. It's not even close to release yet.


You get to even matched players one on Terran and the other on Protoss and Protoss will win almost every time.


I've watched Terran burn protoss many many times, and it wasn't like one player was obviously better than the other.

_________________
"This kind of mob stupidity might be the best evidence around that mankind evolved from cows rather than apes."
— Slashdot user on a post about Black Friday
Tue Sep 11, 2007 6:02 am
View user's profile Send private message   AIM Address XFire Address Post
TS28
1st Lieutenant
1st Lieutenant




Posts: 2078

Reply with quote
100% false. I played SC2 at Blizzcon, and it is by no means 1 sided at all. The mothership is by no means imbalanced whatsoever. It has great damage potentials, but isn't invulnerable. It has a lot of HP, but can die.

It takes an enormous amount of tech, which will be taking away from your expanding/army capabilities at that time. If scouted/anticipated correctly, the other player could establish a lot more map control and or pressure the Toss expo as a counter measure. This is of course assuming that the Toss is going relatively straight to mothership by turtling (Which is a terrible idea).

Spork, the economy theory isn't quite how it works. Actual protoss play style does not involve using large units, though that is somewhat of the lore of the game. The actual play style most times actually includes fast expanding and massing. Neither race really has an overall sense of better units in either SC1 or SC2 in my experience so far.

Facilitator, what the hell are you talking about? "You get to even matched players one on Terran and the other on Protoss and Protoss will win almost every time." ???????????

I do not think you hear nearly the knowledge for the game that you need to in order to make such judgements. I'd imagine this opinion game from "3v3 BGH!!!" "3v3 $$$$ GOGOGO". Protoss is definitely not imbalanced vs Terran, and it's not the other way around either. And no Xelmon, that is not the point of the game, lol. Terran play style in SC1 and seems to carry into SC2 still relies on strong progressive pushes that go throughout the game.
Tue Sep 11, 2007 9:41 am
View user's profile Send private message   AIM Address MSN Messenger Post
Facilitator
Private 1st Class
Private 1st Class




Posts: 49

Reply with quote
Dear lord I've started a monster...

I think I did make my subject a question... Meaning that I don't know the answer. In my limited exp of the first game I've seen Protoss own thats all I'm sayin.

I hereby dub myself SC noob...

_________________
Being pwnd is what I do best.
Tue Sep 11, 2007 10:01 am
View user's profile Send private message   XFire Address Post
TS28
1st Lieutenant
1st Lieutenant




Posts: 2078

Reply with quote
Facilitator wrote:
Dear lord I've started a monster...

I think I did make my subject a question... Meaning that I don't know the answer. In my limited exp of the first game I've seen Protoss own thats all I'm sayin.

I hereby dub myself SC noob...


Sorry, most times when people make threads like "Could this be over powered?" they say things to make it seem like it obviously is, yet still act as if it is a question. Gets aggravating *twitch*. Hearing people say incorrect things about Blizzard games to me is about the same as people saying "BUT IRAQ HAD WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION, WE NEEDED TO SAVE OUR FREEDOM!!!" to me xD

I'm always happy to inform the public though ^^ sorry for being harsh X_X
Tue Sep 11, 2007 10:22 am
View user's profile Send private message   AIM Address MSN Messenger Post
Facilitator
Private 1st Class
Private 1st Class




Posts: 49

Reply with quote
TS28 wrote:


...I'm always happy to inform the public though ^^ sorry for being harsh X_X


It's all good bro.

_________________
Being pwnd is what I do best.
Tue Sep 11, 2007 11:17 am
View user's profile Send private message   XFire Address Post
Church
Specialist
Specialist




Posts: 128

Location:
Eugene, Or

Reply with quote
There's a reason Starcraft is still being played in tournaments, regardless of its crappy resolution and 2bit graphics.

If you saw a terran lose against a toss, chances are either one player was better or the terran didn't build right. There are certain strats versus protoss that you wouldn't carry versus Zerg.

Against Toss: vultures/tanks with turrets and the occasional bunker.
Against Zerg: M&M or goliaths, with a couple tanks and turrets.

Word.

_________________
"This kind of mob stupidity might be the best evidence around that mankind evolved from cows rather than apes."
— Slashdot user on a post about Black Friday
Tue Sep 11, 2007 12:46 pm
View user's profile Send private message   AIM Address XFire Address Post
Display posts from previous:    
PDXLAN Forum Index » PC Games Discussion View next topic
View previous topic
Reply to topic
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to: 
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
Design by Spork and Offbeat Hosting
© 2009 PDXLAN